"How old is it?" is the first question a lot of salespeople ask, and the answer often decides everything. It shouldn’t. Age is one factor. Here’s the framework we actually use.
Repair usually makes sense when
- The repair costs less than roughly a third of a replacement
- The furnace is safe: no confirmed heat-exchanger failure, venting is sound
- It’s been reasonably reliable (not your third repair this winter)
- It heats the house comfortably
Replacement starts to make sense when
- There’s a verified safety problem, shown to you with evidence
- A major part fails (heat exchanger, or an AC compressor) on older equipment
- Repairs are stacking up year after year
- Comfort is bad and the equipment is the cause, not the ductwork
- You’re adding AC or switching to a heat pump anyway
The "multiply" rule of thumb
Some technicians use this: multiply the age of the unit by the repair cost. If it’s over about $5,000, consider replacing. It’s a starting point, not a rule. A $300 igniter on a 20-year-old furnace ($6,000) is still often worth doing if the furnace is otherwise healthy.
What we promise
When we recommend replacement, we show you why: photos, readings and the repair price for comparison. When we recommend repair, we mean it. Start with a free evaluation or get a second opinion on a quote you already have. Costs: 2026 replacement cost guide.
